Experts

Posts relating to expert witnesses.

November 16, 2026

Request for Forensic Examination of Laptop Was Denied

In this breach of contract case arising out of an employment agreement, Defendant asked “that the Court compel Plaintiff to produce his personal laptop for a forensic examination….”  Evans v. Fortiline, Inc., 2026 WL 3216193 (D. Md. Oct. 27, 2026)(Coulson, J).  The former employer, Fortiline, asserted that the former employee, Mr. Evans, […]
October 12, 2026

Are an Expert’s A.I. Prompts Discoverable?  Maybe.

Villanueva v. Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Dept., 2026 WL 2942348 (D. Nev. Sep. 29, 2026),  is the second recent Nevada A.I. decision involving use-of-force expert Tom Melton.  At issue was discovery of the expert’s 40-page ChatGPT history log. The first was discussed in Opposing Expert’s Allegedly Inaccurate Description of Use of A.I. […]
October 8, 2026

Expert’s Use of GenAI Was Proper on Facts Presented

Ferlito v. Harbor Freight Tools USA, Inc., 2025 WL 1181699 (E.D.N.Y. Apr. 23, 2025), isn’t  the most recent decision concerning an expert’s use of GenAI, but it is an interesting one. Mr. Ferlito sued Harbor Freight. He alleged that he purchased a “splitting maul,” which is a specialized axe used to split […]
September 15, 2026

Opposing Expert’s Allegedly Inaccurate Description of Use of A.I. Did Not Justify Modification of Scheduling Order on Facts Presented

“This is a Federal Tort Claims Act case involving allegations of an unlawful shooting by a Bureau of Land Management ranger.”  Martin v. U.S.A., 2026 WL 2582963 (D. Nev. Sep. 1, 2026). Defendant moved to reopen and extend case management deadlines based on Plaintiffs’ expert’s having used AI, allegedly more extensively than […]
August 26, 2026

“‘Show How 3M Is 0% at Fault:’ Expert Witness Used ChatGPT to Write Report Defending Company in Deadly Explosion Lawsuit”

Josh Autenrieth, Laake v. 3M Co., No. 2020-05505-A (11th Dist. Ct. Harris Cty., Tex. July 21, 2026), is not available on Westlaw; however, in this $61 million lawsuit, Jason Koebler’s post, ‘Show How 3M Is 0% at Fault:’ Expert Witness Used ChatGPT to Write Report Defending Company in Deadly Explosion Lawsuit (Aug. […]
July 20, 2026

Discovery From a Dual-Hat Expert

A decision involving a so-called “dual-hat expert” arose out of tragedy.  “This case arises from a flood that swept through Waverly, Tennessee on August 21, 2021 ’killing at least 20 people, including children.’ … Plaintiffs claim that the flood resulted because Defendant allowed debris to clog one of its culverts, which caused […]
June 30, 2026

Stipulated A.I. Order Protects Expert’s Prompts and Outputs

The stipulated protective order in Waterford Township Gen. Employees Retirement System v. Monolithic Power Systems, Inc., 2026 WL 1858112 (W.D. Wash. Jun. 29, 2026), addressed the protection of A.I. used by a party’s expert.  It stated: Neither side must preserve or disclose, including in expert deposition testimony, the following documents or materials:…  […]
January 25, 2026

Does Disclosure of Privileged Information to a “Non-Reporting” or “Hybrid” Expert Waive Privilege?

Plaintiff KISS sought discovery of certain otherwise-privileged communications made by defendant Ardell to Ms. Theresa Cooper, an executive vice president at Ardell.  Initially, Ms. Cooper was designated as a fact witness. Later, she was designated as a “non-reporting expert” pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(a)(2)(c).  The court explained that “Ardell’s Expert Disclosures state that […]
August 9, 2025

Court Finds Subject Matter Waiver in Expert Communications Under Fed.R.Evid. 502(a)

Attorney-expert communications and documents were discoverable under the principle of subject matter waiver of work product and privileged information in Fresh Air for the Eastside, Inc. v. Waste Mgt. of N.Y., LLC, 2025 WL 2107878 (W.D.N.Y. Jul. 28, 2025). FACTS An advocacy group and 94 individuals brought this environmental action against a […]
July 20, 2025

Initial Disclosures Cannot Await Expert Opinions

Lively v. Wayfarer Studios LLC, 2025 WL 1999355 (S.D.N.Y. Jul. 17, 2025), involves a lot of money.  It has also generated a cottage industry of discovery decisions. Westlaw lists 13 decisions (not all on discovery) since February 2025.  For blogs on some of them, please see “It Ends With Us” (Apr. 8, […]
January 28, 2025

Request to Appoint Neutral Forensic Expert Denied as Speculative and Unsupported

In Rivera v. Costco Wholesale Corporation, 2025 WL 295667 (D. P. R. Jan. 24, 2025), the court imposed sanctions on a pro se litigant who, in the court’s words, “has engaged in unseemly behavior towards counsel as well as improper discovery litigation.” In part, Mr. Rivera filed a motion to “To obtain […]
December 17, 2024

Non-Testifying Consultant Subject to Discovery Where Testifying Expert Relied on Consultant’s Work

In Jackson v. Tesla, Inc., 2024 WL 5011620 (N.D. Ca. Dec. 6, 2024), the court held that the work of a non-testifying consultant that was provided to a testifying expert was discoverable. The non-testifying consultant reviewed unintended acceleration complaints in a federal (NHTSA) database.  The consultant used criteria supplied by plaintiffs’ testifying […]
November 20, 2023

“No Expert Needed to Introduce Data Pulled From Phone at Trial”

In No Expert Needed to Introduce Data Pulled From Phone at Trial (bloomberglaw.com) (Oct. 13, 2023), Mr. Peter Hayes reported on  United States v. Williams, 83.F4th 994 (5th Cir. Oct. 13, 2023). Mr. Hayes wrote: “A police officer who introduces evidence extracted from a cellphone at trial doesn’t need to be qualified […]
March 18, 2023

“Here’s what to expect with [proposed] changes to the federal expert witness rule”

Paul Mark Sandler has written an excellent summary, Here’s what to expect with changes to the federal expert witness rule | Maryland Daily Record (thedailyrecord.com)(Mar. 13, 2023). Paul’s article explains the “two important amendments” to  Fed.R.Evid. 702 that are “expected to take effect” in December 2023. He wrote: The pending[1] amended rule […]
August 4, 2022

Proposed Changes to the Maryland Rules Regarding Discovery of Experts

The Maryland Standing Committee on Rules of Practice and Procedure has issued its 211th Report and proposed rules changes. One of the most significant proposals is to modify Rule 2-402 to follow the 2010 amendments to Fed.R.Civ.P. 26 regarding expert discovery.  The Committee explained: In 2010, the Federal Rule was amended to […]
July 17, 2022

Expert Testimony Not Required to Show Ability to Disable Location Tracking on Smartphone

In State v. Galicia, __ Md. __, 2022 WL 2301437, at *1 (June 27, 2022), the Court of Appeals held that expert testimony was not required to show that a user can disable location tracking on a smartphone. Two teenagers were shot by four men in June 2017.  Mr. Galicia was convicted […]
February 17, 2022

Beyond Email – Slack, “Channels,” and Expert Testimony

Mike Hamilton’s blog, “Defendant Ordered to Produce 30,000 Slack Messages” (Exterro Feb. 7, 2022), provides an excellent description of Benebone LLC v. Pet Qwerks, Inc., 2021 WL 831025 (C.D. Cal. Feb. 18, 2021).  The blog correctly points out that, as to discovery of Slack messages, “proportionality was the key issue.” Benebone is […]