In this breach of contract case arising out of an employment agreement, Defendant asked “that the Court compel Plaintiff to produce his personal laptop for a forensic examination….” Evans v. Fortiline, Inc., 2026 WL 3216193 (D. Md. Oct. 27, 2026)(Coulson, J). The former employer, Fortiline, asserted that the former employee, Mr. Evans, was “soliciting a current Fortiline employee to start a competing business in violation of his Employment Agreement.” Plaintiff disputed the allegation. The request for a forensic examination was denied.
THE FACTUAL PREDICATE
Mr. Evans’ use of his personal laptop for Fortiline business was not in dispute:
Defendant asserts that when it first employed Plaintiff, he “performed Fortiline work using his personal Apple laptop computer” after syncing “his Fortiline email account with his Apple email account, which allowed him to access his Fortiline email on his personal laptop.” … Plaintiff does not dispute that he used his personal laptop for Fortiline business for several months, with which he claims Defendant took no issue.
It was undisputed that he had once sent company information to his Gmail account.
In its Request for Production of Documents, however, Defendant “included a request for forensic imaging of all electronic devices used by Plaintiff from March 1, 2025 to present in relation to his employment with Defendant.” In my view, that was a risky request:
Unsurprisingly, Plaintiff refused. However, “Defendant states that Plaintiff also did not produce any emails or other Electronically Stored Information (‘ESI’), but upon review of materials in its possession, Defendant discovered that Plaintiff previously emailed Fortiline information to his personal Gmail containing “confidential/trade secret pricing information….” Plaintiff responded that the email was sent to that account by mistake.
However, “[i]n light of Defendant’s discovery, the parties met and conferred, during which Defendant claims that it learned Plaintiff himself conducted a search of responsive documents, which did not include his personal email or laptop.” To say that was a risky practice is an understatement, especially where the searcher is directly involved in the merits. See:
Plaintiff ran two separate searches for “@fortiline.com” and (2) andrew.evans@fortiline.com…. Additionally, he ran searches for each of the following terms individually: “recruiter,” “headhunter,” “private equity,” “termination,” “fired,” “contract,” “Mark Boring,” “startup,” and “new business.”
Next, Mr. Evans made a supplemental production. Defendant asserted that this supplement “raised additional questions about what happened to the Fortiline information [Plaintiff] emailed to himself during his employment, and whether the searches done to date are adequate to find all responsive ESI.”
And, there was more: “Additionally, Defendant states that on October 12, 2026, it learned that Plaintiff had Fortiline documents on his personal laptop.” Mr. Evans did not deny that but claimed that those documents were “’run of the mill’ and without relevance to any claims or defenses in the current litigation, but such documents will nevertheless be produced.”
To recap, at this juncture, Defendant had made an early request for a forensic examination, it was undisputed that Mr. Evans had used his personal laptop for company business for several months, after a search by Plaintiff apparently without attorney supervision, Mr. Evans initially failed to produce certain responsive materials and did so only after defense inquiry, and even after a supplemental production, Mr. Evans’ production appeared incomplete.
In the Defendant’s words a forensic examination was justified because, “Defendant claims that Plaintiff’s prior ‘piecemeal and lackadaisical approach to searching for responsive documents raises questions about the sufficiency of his search efforts to date.’” In response, “Plaintiff argues that Defendant’s request is not proportional given that he will provide Defendant with relevant non-privileged emails and documents.”
DEFENDANT FAILED TO CARRY ITS BURDEN OF PROOF
The Evans Court first explained that forensic examinations are not lightly ordered:
Courts have been cautious in requiring the mirror imaging of computers where the request is extremely broad in nature and the connection between the computers and the claims in the lawsuit are unduly vague or unsubstantiated in nature…. As this Court has observed, a forensic examination imposes ‘intrusions, costs, and delays making it a “drastic discovery measure…that must be proportional to the needs of the case…. Mere skepticism that an opposing party has not produced all relevant information is not sufficient to warrant drastic electronic discovery measures.”
Id. at *3 (cleaned up).
The Evans Court then set out when a forensic examination may be ordered:
However, restrained and orderly computer forensic examinations have been permitted, where the moving party has demonstrated that the opposing party has defaulted in its discovery obligations by unwillingness or failure to produce relevant information by more conventional means…. In cases where the existence of a document on an electronic device would itself be probative of an issue in dispute, courts are more likely to find that the intrusions, costs, and delays attendant to a forensic examination are proportional to the needs of the case.
Id. (cleaned up).
Next, the Court explained where Fortiline fell short. First, “it fails to suggest that Plaintiff deleted or otherwise destroyed responsive information that could only be obtained through forensic imaging…. Rather, Defendant relies on Plaintiff’s email to his personal Gmail to argue that responsive information is being withheld on the personal laptop. However, Defendants generalized allegations fail to make a showing sufficient to warrant an order allowing for the forensic imaging and examination of Plaintiff’s personal laptop.” Id. at *3.
The Evans Court then looked at Plaintiff’s delay: “Also, while the Court is certainly mindful of Plaintiff’s delays in producing all relevant information to Defendant, both in producing emails and documents on the laptop, it does not find that Plaintiff’s brief delay justifies such an intrusive remedy at this juncture.” Id. at *4.
And, in response to Defendant’s argument that it “is not obligated to take [Plaintiff’s] word about what…information he does/does not still possess,” the Court wrote: “Yet, that is precisely how discovery operates.” Id. at *4 (citation omitted).
Even though Defendant offered to pay the cost of the forensic examination, “both the privacy concerns and concerns about the scope of discovery related to Rule 26 clearly weigh against a forensic examination. Defendant has not carried its burden beyond mere suspicion that forensic imaging Plaintiff’s personal laptop is necessary to uncover relevant evidence unavailable through less intrusive means considering Plaintiff’s representations that no documents have been deleted from his laptop and all responsive information has been or will ultimately be produced.” Id. at *4.
The Court emphasized: “To be clear, Defendant will still receive discovery from Plaintiff’s personal laptop. Even when a forensic examination is not warranted, the Federal Rules require a party to conduct a reasonable search of its files to determine whether it has responsive documents in its possession, custody, or control.” Id. at *4 (cleaned up). And, it left the door open for a future request for a forensic examination upon a factual predicate.