A recent decision followed the concept that Some Unacknowledged A.I. Comes Within the “I’ll know it when I see it” Principle.
“This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiff Jtwain King’s response to the Court’s Order to Show Cause why the Court should not impose sanctions for her failure to abide by applicable rules and her reliance on artificial intelligence to litigate her case for her (including her submission of citations to nonexistent cases in her opposition brief to Defendant Equifax’s motion for judgment on the pleadings)….” King v. AT&T Corp., 2026 WL 3059234, at *1 (W.D. Wash. Oct. 13, 2026)
In her response, King claims that “[n]o generative AI tool was used to draft…any filing in this case” and any duplicate or blank sections in the complaint “may appear to have resulted from formatting or uploading errors when the document was assembled.” … She avers that “[t]o the best of [her] knowledge, [e]very fact and citation in [her] filings were verified through [her] own work aside from minor errors.” … As for the seemingly hallucinated cases, King “acknowledges possible citation verification errors,” but claims that she “did not knowingly fabricate authority” and corrected the errors “through a formal filing” after she discovered them.
The court replied:
The Court takes King at her word with respect to the factual allegations in her complaint, and will therefore not dismiss the remainder of her claims. However, the Court does not find her assertions that the hallucinated cases were merely “citation verification errors” to be credible. As the Court previously observed, “these errors are hallmarks of nonexistent cases created through artificial intelligence,” and “[i]nclusion of nonexistent authority in a brief ‘is plainly a violation of a signer’s certification under Rule 11…. [emphasis added].
The court ordered future disclosure, under oath, of the use of GenAI, with a certification that citations were personally validated.
“Because King has committed to ‘comply with the Court’s directives’ going forward, … the Court elects not to require her to pay the attorney’s fees Equifax incurred in responding to her hallucinated citations.”