“As a preliminary matter, parties’ discovery agreements do not trump their obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.” Johnson v. Southern Ill. Univ. Edwardsville, 2026 WL 3547466 (S.D. Ill. Nov. 18, 2026).
Ms. Johnson sued her employer, the university (“SIUE”), under Title VII, alleging sexual discrimination, harassment, and retaliation. The court entered the parties “ESI Order.”
Following an unsuccessful meet and confer, Ms. Johnson filed a motion to compel based on Request for Production No. 2:
Request for Production No. 2 states: “Please produce any documents or communications regarding or relating to any complaints about Rob Scott and his interactions with any SIUE employees or contractors within the Police Department.”
Among a number of other objections, the university argued that RPD No. 2 “challenges the sufficiency of the protocol…[that] was negotiated and agreed to by the parties…[without] identify[ing] a single responsive document known to exist that SIUE improperly withheld.”
The court wrote:
As a preliminary matter, parties’ discovery agreements do not trump their obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. See In re Loc. TV Advert. Antitrust Litig., No. 18 C 6785, 2023 WL 5659926, at *6 (N.D. Ill. Aug. 31, 2023) (“[discovery] agreements do not control whether [the defendant] has met its discovery obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.”).
Other decisions are in accord. See Is There a Duty to “’Fess Up?” – Part II (Nov. 12, 2022).
The Johnson court added:
Moreover, the ESI protocol to which both parties agreed on May 1, 2026, states similarly…. It specifies that the agreed-upon “search methodologies,” which include “search terms,” do not “relieve [the producing party] of its obligation” to produce “documents and data in its custody or control that are discoverable or responsive to a request for production.” … As such, the fact that Johnson’s request for production requires [the university] to venture beyond the agreed-upon search terms does not automatically render the request improper.
As a final matter, the court added: “Here, while the Court is sympathetic to the challenges of discovery, it is hard-pressed to agree that [the university’s] objections were substantially justified. Nearly all its objections to the request for production were contradicted by the ESI protocol it agreed to and signed—and by the Rules themselves. In other words, this was not a dispute that should have required the Court’s attention.” [emphasis added]. Fees in an amount to be determined were awarded.
Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 states:
Unless the court orders otherwise, the parties may stipulate that:
(a) a deposition may be taken before any person, at any time or place, on any notice, and in the manner specified–in which event it may be used in the same way as any other deposition; and
(b) other procedures governing or limiting discovery be modified–but a stipulation extending the time for any form of discovery must have court approval if it would interfere with the time set for completing discovery, for hearing a motion, or for trial.
The 1993 Advisory Committee Note states: “This rule is revised to give greater opportunity for litigants to agree upon modifications to the procedures governing discovery or to limitations upon discovery. Counsel are encouraged to agree on less expensive and time-consuming methods to obtain information, as through voluntary exchange of documents, use of interviews in lieu of depositions, etc…. Under the revised rule, the litigants ordinarily are not required to obtain the court’s approval of these stipulations.”
Any exclusion should be specific. See ESI Protocol Did Not Fully Describe a Metadata Privilege Log (forthcoming on November 23rd).