Biotronik:  AI Protective Order

Disclosure of Expert’s A.I. Prompts Ordered – Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 Stipulation Was Silent
November 21, 2026
“Hallucinated Cases” Explanation Deemed Not Credible
November 22, 2026

“Protective orders are an exception to the general rule that pretrial discovery must occur in the public eye…. Here, the Court is satisfied that Biotronik brings its motion in good faith and has demonstrated good cause for the entry of a protective order. Specifically, good cause exists because ‘discovery will require Biotronik to disclose trade secrets and other highly sensitive priority information to NPH.’”  Biotronik Inc. v. Niazi Patent Holdings LLC, 2026 WL 3572636 (E.D. Wis. Nov. 20, 2026).

For more information on AI Protective Orders, please click the “Categories” dropdown menu at the upper right and select “AI Protective Orders.”

The Biotronik court resolved several disputes and established “parameters for the use of Artificial Intelligence as it pertains to confidential documents, see infra Paragraph (L).”  Paragraph (L) provides:

(L) USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (“AI”)

A receiving party may use AI tools in connection with discovery materials produced in this action only if the AI tool is operated in a secure environment and is subject to enforceable contractual terms that (a) prohibit the provider from retaining, using, disclosing, selling, or using the materials to train, improve, or develop any AI system; (b) prohibit the materials from being made publicly available or accessible to any other customer or third party; and (c) require commercially reasonable administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect the confidentiality of the materials. Discovery materials, whether designated CONFIDENTIAL or ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY, shall not be entered into any publicly available or consumer-based AI platform. Any use of AI tools must remain consistent with this Order and with the requirement that discovery materials be used solely for purposes of this litigation.

As set forth in prior posts, AI Protective Orders present a number of drafting issues and may negatively impact on the access to justice in asymmetric cases. Biotronik appears to have taken a functional approach.

Share