Smotherman v. Hodge, 2026 WL 3521483 (D. Nev. Nov. 16, 2026), involved 16 non-dispositive discovery and sanctions motions. “This defamation action arises from a Facebook post in which Defendants published Plaintiff’s photograph, mistaking him for someone else…. Plaintiff is the pastor of Legacy Church in New Mexico.”
This post focuses on one issue—discovery of an expert’s use of AI.
“Defendants move to compel Plaintiff to respond to Interrogatory Nos. 23 and 24 and Request for Production Nos. 57 through 62, which ask whether and how Plaintiff’s experts used artificial intelligence in preparing their reports.” After part of that motion was mooted by Plaintiff’s withdrawal of one expert, it was granted in part.
The court wrote:
Subparts (1) through (4) of Interrogatory No. 23 ask whether Mr. Fisher used an artificial intelligence tool in preparing his report and, if so, how…. Plaintiff objects that the interrogatory exceeds the numerical limit and seeks protected draft material….
This Court overrules those objections. Rule 26(b)(4)’s protections “do not impede discovery about the opinions to be offered by the expert or the development, foundation, or basis of those opinions.”... An expert’s own use of a tool in developing his opinions goes to the basis of those opinions, and these subparts do not ask for draft reports or communications with counsel. To the extent the interrogatory exceeds the numerical limit, this Court grants Defendants leave to serve it as narrowed, because a single question about Mr. Fisher’s methodology is relevant and proportional to the needs of the case. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1), 33(a)(1).
Within 14 days of this order, Plaintiff must serve a verified answer to subparts (1) through (4) of Interrogatory No. 23. If Mr. Fisher did not use an artificial intelligence tool in preparing his report, Plaintiff may answer by saying so. Plaintiff need not disclose draft reports or communications between counsel and Mr. Fisher, except as described in Section II.F.4.
Both sides request their expenses…. Because most of Defendants’ motion became moot after Plaintiff withdrew Dr. Jonyer, and the remaining request is granted only as narrowed, this Court declines to award expenses to either side.
Id. at *13 (cleaned up).
Another court recently took a more nuanced approach. Expert’s Use of GenAI Was Proper on Facts Presented (Oct. 8, 2026).
For more information, please visit: