An ESI Protocol is Not Rule-Mandated – A “Discovery Plan” Is Mandated

Dunn: An Interesting AI Protective Order Analysis Uses a Functional Definition
November 16, 2026

Plaintiff’s civil rights suit against several police officers arose out of his arrest after a traffic stop.  Parts of the occurrence were recorded by police cameras.  Plaintiff alleged “unlawful prolongation of the stop, unlawful search of the vehicle, false arrest, unlawful seizure of currency, and malicious prosecution.”

Plaintiff filed a “Motion for Entry of a Proposed Order Governing Discovery of Electronically Stored Information.” It was described as a motion to enter an ESI Protocol.  Defendants filed an opposition and the motion was denied without prejudice.  Halle v. Jansen, 2026 WL 3458066 (S.D. Ill. Nov. 13, 2026). The court wrote:

“Entry of an ESI protocol is not rule-mandated. Absent a stipulation by the parties, the party seeking the entry of an ESI protocol has the burden of showing that there is good cause for its adoption.”

Id. at *1 (emphasis added).

Plaintiff failed, in my opinion, by seeking an ESI Protocol, instead of a “discovery plan,” and because of lack of an adequate factual foundation for a preservation order.

As to the failure to provide a foundation, the court wrote that “the motion does not address why an ESI protocol is necessary in this case….”  Id.

However, the request was in significant part for a preservation order: “The proposed ESI protocol governs the preservation and identification of relevant ESI and provides for its production in a native format with metadata maintained.”  Id.

The court gave two reasons why an ESI Protocol was not needed to achieve these goals. Id.

First, Fed.R.Civ.P. 34 allows Plaintiff to file a request for production of ESI and specify the form or forms of production.

Second, as to preservation: “Defendants explain that CPD uses Axon for its camera services. Axon’s system collects data directly from CPD’s cameras and stores it on a cloud-based system. That system ‘generates permanent, tamper-proof audit trails that automatically log every action, such as viewing, editing, or sharing a file.’ … Defendants represent that while CPD can redact videos stored on Axon’s servers and create new videos as needed, all revisions are noted in Axon’s audit trails. As such, Plaintiff will have the ability to determine whether any produced videos have been edited. Defendants further state that they do not object to the production of original copies of relevant videos in their possession along with the corresponding audit trail for each video. Plaintiff will also be able to subpoena Axon if deemed necessary.”

On those facts, the court wrote: “Plaintiff has not filed a reply addressing Defendants’ objections or otherwise demonstrating the necessity for the entry of the proposed ESI protocol. Based on the record before it, the Court finds that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure in place adequately address any needs for ESI discovery in this case. Accordingly, the Motion for Entry of a Proposed Order Governing Discovery of Electronically Stored Information… is DENIED without prejudice.”  Id. at *2.

I suggest that Plaintiff misfired in two ways.  It is often important to use the correct words.  In “Through the Looking Glass,” Lewis Carroll wrote: “When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’”

First, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure do not mention an “ESI Protocol.”  However, they do require a “discovery plan.”  “ESI Protocol” v. “Discovery Plan” – E-Discovery LLC (Jan. 2, 2024); An “ESI Protocol” is Not a Rule 26(f) “Discovery Plan” – E-Discovery LLC (Nov. 24, 2025).  A “discovery plan” includes all aspects of an ESI Protocol; however, an ESI Protocol may not suffice as a “discovery plan.”  Rule 26(f)(1) requires a conference of the parties “as soon as practicable….”  Under Rule 26(f)(2), the parties must submit “to the court within 14 days after the conference a written report outlining the [discovery] plan.”   A discovery plan is robust and defined in Rule 26(f)(3). Under Fed.R.Civ.P. 37(f): “If a party or its attorney fails to participate in good faith in developing and submitting a proposed discovery plan as required by Rule 26(f), the court may, after giving an opportunity to be heard, require that party or attorney to pay to any other party the reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, caused by the failure.”  See also Failure to Cooperate Leads to Judicially-Imposed ESI Protocol – E-Discovery LLC (Jan. 15, 2025).

Second, there is a well-developed body of case law governing preservation orders. The Standard for a Preservation Order – E-Discovery LLC (Oct. 21, 2026).   A movant must provide the factual predicate:  “The parties generally agree that courts considering a preservation order should assess (i) the degree of concern that evidence will be destroyed, (ii) the risk of irreparable harm to the requesting party, and (iii) the preserving party’s capability to maintain the evidence in question.”  Id. (citation omitted).  Another test is whether the party seeking preservation can demonstrate both that an order is necessary and not unduly burdensome. Id. (citation omitted).  While the Plaintiff in Halle appears to have failed to make such a demonstration, Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(f) states topics that “the parties must consider” in a conference of the parties a/k/a a “meet and confer.”  One of them is to “discuss any issues about preserving discoverable information….” Further, the “discovery plan” developed by the parties should address “any issues about… preservation of electronically stored information….”  Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(f)(3)(C).  That rules-based discussion is not predicated on a showing of necessity.

In “Alice in Wonderland,” Lewis Carroll wrote “Begin at the beginning and go on till you come to the end: then stop.”  The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are a good starting point.

This blog was initially posted on  Electronic Discovery Reference Model.

Share