Two recent decisions rejected the argument that billing should be reduced because AI was used. One illustrated the “verification-value paradox.” The other permitted fee recovery where AI supplemented manual efforts. While A.I. may save time, the output must be verified and the hours reasonably spent in verification are properly billable.
In The “Verification-Value Paradox”: No Evidence That Counsel’s Use of AI Should Have Decreased Billing, I wrote about Flux Drive, Inc. v. Rong, __ F.4th __, 2026 WL 3266333 (10th Cir. Oct. 30, 2026), where the court rejected an argument that, because A.I. was used, fewer hours should have been billed. The court wrote that “ethical rules require counsel to verify the cases cited and to ensure that all arguments are grounded in legal authority…. Thus, even assuming that AI and other research tools might make attorneys more efficient in the long run—and, in some circumstances, might thereby reduce the hours necessary to litigate a case—Plaintiffs have not shown that defense counsel’s use of AI rendered the hours that they actually expended unreasonable.”
Donavan Realty, LLC v. Campers Inn Holding Corp., 2026 WL 3521324, at *12(E.D. Pa. Nov. 16, 2026), reached a similar result. Donavan “was no standard litigation….” Id. at *7. It involved years of litigation, a change of counsel before trial, and was on remand from the Third Circuit.
In Donavan, Plaintiffs filed a petition for fees arising out of a prevailing parties clause in an asset purchase agreement for the failed sale of two recreational vehicle dealerships. The claimant “submitted hundreds of pages of billing records” and “thousands of hours’ worth of time entries….” The court wrote:
[Defendants] Campers Inn also seeks a reduction of the award on the basis that BNRV used artificial intelligence (“AI”) to summarize the [Plaintiffs’ attorneys] Klehr Harrison billing records instead of reviewing them thoroughly for reasonableness as is required. This misstates the record. [Plaintiffs] BNRV did provide the Court with an AI-generated “approximation of the hours expended by Klehr Harrison, by activity.” But there is no indication that this AI-generated summary stood in for manual review of the billing records. Indeed, the summary appears in the same paragraph of DeSiderato’s Declaration in which he mentions “Dilworth’s manual review of the Klehr invoices,” and only three paragraphs down from a description of the review. The Court sees no reason to reduce the fee award based on the use of AI to generate the summary, as it was utilized to supplement, rather than replace, manual review. [emphasis added].
Under governing New York law, contractual fee petitions are strictly construed. Id. at *4. The court awarded $2,442,009.77 in fees and prejudgment interest of $79,50.00.