<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>ESI &#8211; E-Discovery LLC</title>
	<atom:link href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/category/esi/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com</link>
	<description>Mediation of E-Discovery Disputes</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 17:20:28 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-US</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>1</sy:updateFrequency>
	
	<item>
		<title>Disclosure of Expert’s A.I. Prompts Ordered – Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 Stipulation Was Silent</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/disclosure-of-experts-a-i-prompts-ordered-fed-r-civ-p-29-stipulation-was-silent/</link>
		<pubDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 17:20:28 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Commercial Litigation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ESI Protocol a/k/a Discovery Plans]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Experts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Important Posts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Software]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Conference of Parties]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Discoverability]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Forensics]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5818</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[In a decision issued yesterday, a Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 stipulation provided that expert’s “notes” were not discoverable. An expert’s prompts or queries were not “notes.” The court also held that the prompts were &#8220;reliance materials&#8221; that were  discoverable under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure: Here, the Court concludes that artificial intelligence prompts<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In a decision issued yesterday, a Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 stipulation provided that expert’s “notes” were not discoverable. An expert’s prompts or queries were not “notes.” The court also held that the prompts were &#8220;reliance materials&#8221; that were  discoverable under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure:</p>
<blockquote><p>Here, the Court concludes that artificial intelligence prompts or queries used by Dr. Oreskes or her team in the course of producing her expert witness report is discoverable under Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) because they comprise “the basis” for the opinions that Dr. Oreskes will express.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Conservation Law Foundation, Inc. v. Equilon Enterprises LLC,</em> 2026 WL 3571573, at *4 (D. Conn. Nov. 20, 2026).</p>
<p>Discovery of expert’s use of AI, and the manner of use, is a hot topic:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/are-an-experts-a-i-prompts-discoverable-maybe/">Are an Expert’s A.I. Prompts Discoverable?  Maybe</a> (Oct. 12, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/experts-use-of-genai-was-proper-on-facts-presented/">Expert’s Use of GenAI Was Proper on Facts Presented</a> (Oct. 8, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/opposing-experts-allegedly-inaccurate-description-of-use-of-a-i-did-not-justify-modification-of-scheduling-order-on-facts-presented/">Opposing Expert’s Allegedly Inaccurate Description of Use of A.I. Did Not Justify Modification of Scheduling Order on Facts Presented</a> (Sep. 15, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/show-how-3m-is-0-at-fault-expert-witness-used-chatgpt-to-write-report-defending-company-in-deadly-explosion-lawsuit/">“‘Show How 3M Is 0% at Fault:’ Expert Witness Used ChatGPT to Write Report Defending Company in Deadly Explosion Lawsuit”</a> (Aug. 26, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/stipulated-a-i-order-protects-experts-prompts-and-outputs/">Stipulated A.I. Order Protects Expert’s Prompts and Outputs</a> (Jun. 30, 2026).</li>
</ul>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>THE FACTS: HOW WAS AI USED?</u></strong></p>
<p>In <em>Conservation Law Foundation</em> (“<em>CLF</em>”)<em>,</em> the District Court affirmed a Magistrate Judge’s “order compelling production of reliance materials related to the use of artificial intelligence.”  CLF filed an environmental suit three companies challenging a bulk storage and fuel terminal in Connecticut.</p>
<blockquote><p>As is relevant to the current objections, Plaintiff engaged Dr. Naomi Oreskes, the Charles Henry Lea Professor of the History of Science and Affiliated Professor of Earth and Planetary Sciences at Harvard University, to be an expert witness in this case. In writing the opening report, Dr. Oreskes relied on materials produced in this litigation, and employed a computational scientist, Dr. Alexander A. Kaurov, as a research assistant to assist with her review of materials produced in this litigation. After Plaintiff provided access to the documents produced in this action, Dr. Kaurov processed those documents using a dedicated Microsoft Azure cloud environment created solely for the project. <em>To review and search the produced documents in this litigation, prompts, queries, and model outputs were used interactively as intermediate tools to identify potentially relevant documents for further review. Dr. Kaurov used ChatGPT to search for documents and to identify the documents for Dr. Oreskes to review. While doing so, Dr. Kaurov did not preserve complete native “prompt/output log” standalone files on any personal systems or in a cloud environment</em>.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *2 (emphasis added). Chat GPT was used “on a secure server.” <em>Id</em>. at n. 14.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>THE DISPUTE</u></strong></p>
<p>Defendant’s position was based on Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(a)(2)(B):</p>
<blockquote><p>On December 23, 2025, Defendants moved to compel production of artificial intelligence (“AI”) reliance materials. Defendants argued that Plaintiff violated Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(B) by refusing to produce the underlying facts, data, and documents that construct the methodology Dr. Oreskes relied on to use AI. Defendants noted that Dr. Oreskes relied on an AI workflow to form substantive opinions in her expert report and that she and Dr. Kaurov jointly developed prompts used to analyze Defendants’ document production.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *2.  The parties conferred, were unable to reach agreement, and after briefing the Magistrate Judge granted the motion to compel. The matter was before the District Court on Plaintiff’s objections.  The District Judge affirmed.</p>
<p>The materials had been requested in an email.  The court “easily” rejected Plaintiff’s argument that it was error to enforce “informal” discovery requests, finding the argument was waived. <em>Id</em>. at *2. “But the Court exercises its discretion here to note that it was neither clearly erroneous nor contrary to law to compel production of materials requested through email.” <em>Id</em>. at *3.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>THE FED.R.CIV.P. 29 STIPULATION</u></strong></p>
<p>After rejecting an argument that the motion was untimely: “The Court similarly rejects the argument that the Magistrate Judge misinterpreted the parties’ stipulation under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 29(b).”  It wrote:</p>
<blockquote><p>Here, there is no dispute that the parties are bound by a Rule 29 stipulation, which includes the following Non-Discoverability provision:</p>
<p><strong>Non-Discoverability:</strong> Drafts of expert reports and communications between experts, employees and  consultants of Party-related entities on expert opinions or settlement-related issues, including emails, notes, and other correspondence, shall not be subject to discovery. This includes any preliminary findings or informal discussions that have occurred between experts employees or consultants of Party-related entities.</p>
<p>Thus, the parties stipulated to remove certain categories of documents related to the expert report drafting process from discovery, including drafts, communications, emails, notes, and other correspondence.</p></blockquote>
<p>The <em>CLF</em> court explained:</p>
<blockquote><p>It was not clearly erroneous for the Magistrate Judge to distinguish AI prompts or queries from the categories of documents in the agreement here, where the agreement does not even mention the use of artificial intelligence. “Prompts,” as referenced here and in Dr. Kaurov’s declaration, refers to how users interact with ChatGPT. ChatGPT’s official website indicates that “(p)rompting is how you tell ChatGPT what you want to know, make, or change” and that “[a] prompt can be a question, an instruction, or a goal.” The website further provides that, after reviewing the response from ChatGPT, users can “use follow-up messages to shape the result.” Against this backdrop, it was not clearly erroneous for the Magistrate Judge to conclude that AI prompts are distinguishable from an expert’s “notes” related to draft expert opinions and to reject the interpretation of the stipulation in a way that excluded AI prompts from the universe of discoverable materials.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *4.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>THE FED.R.CIV.P.  26 ANALYSIS</u></strong></p>
<p>Having decided the issue based on the Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 stipulation, the <em>CLF</em> court also rejected Plaintiff’s objections on the merits, under Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(b)(relevance).</p>
<blockquote><p>As to Rule 26(b), this Court concurs with the reasoning provided by the Magistrate Judge in granting the motion to compel. The Magistrate Judge did not clearly err in concluding that <em>an expert witness’s methodology is fair ground for discovery. </em>Plaintiff’s objection does not instill in the Court a conviction that the Magistrate Judge erred, because <em>this Court concludes that the process by which Dr. Oreskes culled down the defendants’ document production into a subset to be worked with falls within the scope of discovery, as it is nonprivileged matter that is relevant</em> to a party’s claim or defense and proportional to needs of the case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b). [Magistrate] Judge Farrish adequately considered how Defendants satisfied the “relatively low threshold for a party to show that the material sought is relevant to any claim or defense in the litigation.”</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *4 (emphasis added).</p>
<p>The <em>CLF</em> court then looked at Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(a)(2)(B) and held that it also compelled disclosure of “artificial intelligence prompts and queries used by Dr. Oreskes or her team in the course of producing her expert witness report.” It wrote that “Witnesses who are specially employed to provide expert testimony in a case have an affirmative duty to provide a report containing ‘a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them;’ and “the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them. Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(2)(B)(i), (ii)….”  It explained:</p>
<blockquote><p><em>ChatGPT’s website indicates that “<p>rompting is how you tell ChatGPT what you want to know, make, or change” and that, as part of the prompting process, users can “use follow-up messages to shape the result.”</em> To review and search the produced documents in this litigation with ChatGPT, Dr. Oreskes or Dr. Kaurov <em>used prompts or queries and model outputs as an intermediate tool</em> to identify potentially relevant documents for further review. At her deposition, Dr. Oreskes testified that she used “AI as a sieve to identify all the documents that could be relevant to a particular question” and to “go through all of the documents provided by the Defendant to find all of the documents that mention sea level rise.” To do this, Dr. Oreskes discussed with her research assistant what the prompts would be and reviewed the documents after the analysis was run. <em>Thus, it appears that the prompts and queries comprise the basis for Dr. Oreskes’s opinions</em>.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *4 (emphasis added).</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>THE “PROMPTS NO LONGER EXIST” ARGUMENT</u></strong></p>
<p>Plaintiff contended that the prompts no longer existed. “Finally, the Court rejects Plaintiff’s argument that the Magistrate Judge erred in compelling production of materials that, based on counsel’s representations, do not exist.”  <em>Id</em>. at *5.</p>
<blockquote><p>[Magistrate] Judge Farrish did not clearly err in concluding that <em>there was an evidence-backed reason for doubting Plaintiff’s representation that materials never existed.</em> Dr. Oreskes’s assistant, Dr. Kaurov, referenced “prompt[s]” in his declaration. Specifically, to review and search the produced documents in this litigation, Dr. Kaurov represents that prompts or queries and model outputs were used interactively as an intermediate tool to identify potentially relevant documents for further review. Indeed, Dr. Oreskes discussed Dr. Kaurov, her research assistant, what the prompts would be and reviewed the documents after the analysis was run. The testimony under penalty of perjury provided by Dr. Kaurov and Dr. Oreskes comprise “solid evidence” that AI prompts or queries used by Drs. Oreskes and Kaurov existed at one time, and thus, an order of production is warranted.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *5.  Plaintiff’s objections to the Magistrate Judge’s order were overruled and the order affirmed in its entirety.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Parties’ Discovery Agreements Do Not Trump the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/parties-discovery-agreements-do-not-trump-the-federal-rules-of-civil-procedure/</link>
		<pubDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 10:58:56 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Conference of Parties]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Discoverability]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Rules]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Search]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5812</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[“As a preliminary matter, parties’ discovery agreements do not trump their obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.”  Johnson v. Southern Ill. Univ. Edwardsville, 2026 WL 3547466 (S.D. Ill. Nov. 18, 2026). Ms. Johnson sued her employer, the university (“SIUE”), under Title VII, alleging sexual discrimination, harassment, and retaliation.  The court<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“As a preliminary matter, parties’ discovery agreements do not trump their obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.”  <em>Johnson v. Southern Ill. Univ. Edwardsville</em>, 2026 WL 3547466 (S.D. Ill. Nov. 18, 2026).</p>
<p>Ms. Johnson sued her employer, the university (“SIUE”), under Title VII, alleging sexual discrimination, harassment, and retaliation.  The court entered the parties “ESI Order.”</p>
<p>Following an unsuccessful meet and confer, Ms. Johnson filed a motion to compel based on Request for Production No. 2:</p>
<blockquote><p>Request for Production No. 2 states: “Please produce any documents or communications regarding or relating to any complaints about Rob Scott and his interactions with any SIUE employees or contractors within the Police Department.”</p></blockquote>
<p>Among a number of other objections, the university argued that RPD No. 2 “challenges the sufficiency of the protocol&#8230;[that] was negotiated and agreed to by the parties&#8230;[without] identify[ing] a single responsive document known to exist that SIUE improperly withheld.”</p>
<p>The court wrote:</p>
<blockquote><p>As a preliminary matter, <em>parties’ discovery agreements do not trump their obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure</em>. <em>See In re Loc. TV Advert. Antitrust Litig.</em>, No. 18 C 6785, 2023 WL 5659926, at *6 (N.D. Ill. Aug. 31, 2023) (“[discovery] agreements do not control whether [the defendant] has met its discovery obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.”).</p></blockquote>
<p>Other decisions are in accord. <em>See</em> <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/is-there-a-duty-to-fess-up-part-ii/">Is There a Duty to “’Fess Up?” – Part II</a> (Nov. 12, 2022).</p>
<p>The <em>Johnson </em>court added:</p>
<blockquote><p>Moreover, the ESI protocol to which both parties agreed on May 1, 2026, states similarly…. It specifies that the agreed-upon “search methodologies,” which include “search terms,” do not “relieve [the producing party] of its obligation” to produce “documents and data in its custody or control that are discoverable or responsive to a request for production.” &#8230; As such, the fact that Johnson’s request for production requires [the university] to venture beyond the agreed-upon search terms does not automatically render the request improper.</p></blockquote>
<p>As a final matter, the court added: “Here, while the Court is sympathetic to the challenges of discovery, it is hard-pressed to agree that [the university’s] objections were substantially justified. <em>Nearly all its objections to the request for production were contradicted by the ESI protocol it agreed to and signed—and by the Rules themselves. In other words, this was not a dispute that should have required the Court’s attention</em>.” [emphasis added].  Fees in an amount to be determined were awarded.</p>
<p>Fed.R.Civ.P. 29 states:</p>
<blockquote><p>Unless the court orders otherwise, the parties may stipulate that:</p>
<p>(a) a deposition may be taken before any person, at any time or place, on any notice, and in the manner specified&#8211;in which event it may be used in the same way as any other deposition; and</p>
<p>(b) other procedures governing or limiting discovery be modified&#8211;but a stipulation extending the time for any form of discovery must have court approval if it would interfere with the time set for completing discovery, for hearing a motion, or for trial.</p></blockquote>
<p>The 1993 Advisory Committee Note states: “This rule is revised to give greater opportunity for litigants to agree upon modifications to the procedures governing discovery or to limitations upon discovery. Counsel are encouraged to agree on less expensive and time-consuming methods to obtain information, as through voluntary exchange of documents, use of interviews in lieu of depositions, etc….  Under the revised rule, the litigants ordinarily are not required to obtain the court&#8217;s approval of these stipulations.”</p>
<p>Any exclusion should be specific.  <em>See</em> <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/esi-protocol-did-not-fully-describe-a-metadata-privilege-log/">ESI Protocol Did Not Fully Describe a Metadata Privilege Log</a> (forthcoming on November 23<sup>rd</sup>).</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“Kenwood students sue after AI gun alert mistakes Doritos bag for weapon”</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/kenwood-students-sue-after-ai-gun-alert-mistakes-doritos-bag-for-weapon/</link>
		<pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 10:15:24 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[News Stories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5794</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[In an article by Christopher Scarglato and Jessica Baugh, the Baltimore Sun reported that Kenwood students sue after AI gun alert mistakes Doritos bag for weapon (Nov. 19, 2026). Current and former high school students sued “after an artificial intelligence system mistook a bag of Doritos as a gun….”  Id.  The gun<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In an article by Christopher Scarglato and Jessica Baugh, the Baltimore Sun reported that <a href="https://digitaledition.baltimoresun.com/shortcode/6B596A/edition/dd590be3-6fd9-4c99-8d07-d078da00b9a6?page=1a4c9960-c88c-49ca-9ea2-46c1550e37b9&amp;">Kenwood students sue after AI gun alert mistakes Doritos bag for weapon</a> (Nov. 19, 2026).</p>
<p>Current and former high school students sued “after an artificial intelligence system mistook a bag of Doritos as a gun….”  <em>Id</em>.  The gun detection system issued an alert. “At least six Baltimore County Police Department vehicles responded to the school, with officers drawing their guns, the suit alleges. Police ordered the students to their knees, then separated and handcuffed them. The police found no weapons.”  <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p>There was a “human in the loop.”  “According to the complaint, … a county schools safety manager, and a Baltimore County police sergeant reviewed the alert and determined it to be a false alarm within two minutes.  The alert was canceled and a cancelation notice was sent to all recipients.”  <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p>More than 10 minutes after cancellation, the principal took a screenshot of the alert and sent it to a school resource officer, who forwarded it to the police department.  Later—it is not reported how long later—the resource officer sent a text saying “bag of chips not a gun” with a crying-laughing emoji. <em>Id</em>.  The principal responded “Bwahahaha.”</p>
<p>The complaint alleges that the gun detection system was unreliable.  “One police officer told the students, “AI is not the best.’”</p>
<p>This post is based on the newspaper report of allegations in a Complaint.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The “Verification-Value Paradox”:  No Evidence That Counsel’s Use of AI Should Have Decreased Billing – Part II</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/the-verification-value-paradox-no-evidence-that-counsels-use-of-ai-should-have-decreased-billing-part-ii/</link>
		<pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 09:39:31 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Commercial Litigation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5798</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Two recent decisions rejected the argument that billing should be reduced because AI was used.  One illustrated the “verification-value paradox.”  The other permitted fee recovery where AI supplemented manual efforts.  While A.I. may save time, the output must be verified and the hours reasonably spent in verification are properly billable. In The<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Two recent decisions rejected the argument that billing should be reduced because AI was used.  One illustrated the “verification-value paradox.”  The other permitted fee recovery where AI supplemented manual efforts.  While A.I. may save time, the output must be verified and the hours reasonably spent in verification are properly billable.</p>
<p>In <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/the-verification-value-paradox-no-evidence-that-counsels-use-of-ai-should-have-decreased-billing/">The “Verification-Value Paradox”:  No Evidence That Counsel’s Use of AI Should Have Decreased Billing</a>, I wrote about <em>Flux Drive, Inc. v. Rong</em>, __ F.4th __, 2026 WL 3266333 (10th Cir. Oct. 30, 2026), where the court rejected an argument that, because A.I. was used, fewer hours should have been billed.  The court wrote that “ethical rules require counsel to verify the cases cited and to ensure that all arguments are grounded in legal authority…. Thus, even assuming that AI and other research tools might make attorneys more efficient in the long run—and, in some circumstances, might thereby reduce the hours necessary to litigate a case—Plaintiffs have not shown that defense counsel’s use of AI rendered the hours that they actually expended unreasonable.”</p>
<p><em>Donavan Realty, LLC v. Campers Inn Holding Corp.,</em> 2026 WL 3521324, at *12(E.D. Pa. Nov. 16, 2026), reached a similar result. <em>Donavan</em> “was no standard litigation….” <em>Id</em>. at *7.  It involved years of litigation, a change of counsel before trial, and was on remand from the Third Circuit.</p>
<p>In <em>Donavan, </em>Plaintiffs filed a petition for fees arising out of a prevailing parties clause in an asset purchase agreement for the failed sale of two recreational vehicle dealerships.  The claimant “submitted hundreds of pages of billing records” and “thousands of hours’ worth of time entries….”  The court wrote:</p>
<blockquote><p><em>[Defendants] Campers Inn also seeks a reduction of the award on the basis that BNRV used artificial intelligence (“AI”) to summarize the [Plaintiffs’ attorneys]</em> <em>Klehr Harrison billing records</em> instead of reviewing them thoroughly for reasonableness as is required. This misstates the record. [Plaintiffs] BNRV did provide the Court with an AI-generated “approximation of the hours expended by Klehr Harrison, by activity.” <em>But there is no indication that this AI-generated summary stood in for manual review of the billing records. Indeed, the summary appears in the same paragraph of DeSiderato’s Declaration in which he mentions “Dilworth’s manual review of the Klehr invoices,”</em> and only three paragraphs down from a description of the review. <em>The Court sees no reason to reduce the fee award based on the use of AI to generate the summary, as it was utilized to supplement, rather than replace, manual review.</em> [emphasis added].</p></blockquote>
<p>Under governing New York law, contractual fee petitions are strictly construed. <em>Id</em>. at *4.  The court awarded $2,442,009.77 in fees and prejudgment interest of $79,50.00.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Law360: “DOJ Refers 2 AUSAs For Potential Discipline Over AI Use”</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/law360-doj-refers-2-ausas-for-potential-discipline-over-ai-use/</link>
		<pubDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 20:30:17 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[News Stories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Software]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ethics]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5800</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Law360 reports that “DOJ Refers 2 AUSAs For Potential Discipline Over AI Use”: One of the unnamed attorneys was caught uploading documents covered by a tribunal&#8217;s protective order into a public AI platform. Other documents contained department employees&#8217; personally identifiable information, including medical information, according to the DOJ&#8217;s Office of Professional Responsibility, which<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Law360 reports that “DOJ Refers 2 AUSAs For Potential Discipline Over AI Use”:</p>
<blockquote><p>One of the unnamed attorneys was caught uploading documents covered by a tribunal&#8217;s protective order into a public AI platform. Other documents contained department employees&#8217; personally identifiable information, including medical information, according to the DOJ&#8217;s Office of Professional Responsibility, which concluded that the attorney &#8220;recklessly violated the rules of professional conduct.&#8221;</p>
<p>The other AUSA allegedly failed to admit to using AI after a judge asked him to explain misstated rulings and fabricated quotes in a court filing. The OPR said he claimed to have inadvertently filed a draft document, and then continued to misrepresent his AI use during a subsequent court hearing.</p></blockquote>
<p>Andrea Keckley, <a href="https://www.law360.com/legalethics/articles/2551636?nl_pk=4a61fd8d-3bbf-420c-b45e-10620a60eb4d&amp;utm_source=newsletter&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_campaign=legalethics&amp;utm_content=2026-11-19&amp;read_more=1&amp;nlsidx=0&amp;nlaidx=1">DOJ Refers 2 AUSAs For Potential Discipline Over AI Use &#8211; Law360</a> (Nov. 18, 2026).</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Discovery of Expert’s Use of A.I.</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/discovery-of-experts-use-of-a-i/</link>
		<pubDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 10:11:28 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ESI Protocol a/k/a Discovery Plans]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Discoverability]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5789</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Smotherman v. Hodge, 2026 WL 3521483 (D. Nev. Nov. 16, 2026), involved 16 non-dispositive discovery and sanctions motions.  “This defamation action arises from a Facebook post in which Defendants published Plaintiff’s photograph, mistaking him for someone else…. Plaintiff is the pastor of Legacy Church in New Mexico.” This post focuses on one<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Smotherman v. Hodge</em>, 2026 WL 3521483 (D. Nev. Nov. 16, 2026), involved 16 non-dispositive discovery and sanctions motions.  “This defamation action arises from a Facebook post in which Defendants published Plaintiff’s photograph, mistaking him for someone else…. Plaintiff is the pastor of Legacy Church in New Mexico.”</p>
<p>This post focuses on one issue—discovery of an expert’s use of AI.</p>
<p>“Defendants move to compel Plaintiff to respond to Interrogatory Nos. 23 and 24 and Request for Production Nos. 57 through 62, which ask whether and how Plaintiff’s experts used artificial intelligence in preparing their reports.”  After part of that motion was mooted by Plaintiff’s withdrawal of one expert, it was granted in part.</p>
<p>The court wrote:</p>
<blockquote><p>Subparts (1) through (4) of Interrogatory No. 23 ask whether Mr. Fisher used an artificial intelligence tool in preparing his report and, if so, how…. <em>Plaintiff objects that the interrogatory</em> exceeds the numerical limit and <em>seeks protected draft material</em>….</p>
<p><em>This Court overrules those objections. Rule 26(b)(4)’s protections “do not impede discovery about the opinions to be offered by the expert or the development, foundation, or basis of those opinions.”..</em>. An expert’s own use of a tool in developing his opinions goes to the basis of those opinions, and these subparts do not ask for draft reports or communications with counsel. To the extent the interrogatory exceeds the numerical limit, this Court grants Defendants leave to serve it as narrowed, because a single question about Mr. Fisher’s methodology is relevant and proportional to the needs of the case. <em>See</em> Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1), 33(a)(1).</p>
<p>Within 14 days of this order, Plaintiff must serve a verified answer to subparts (1) through (4) of Interrogatory No. 23. If Mr. Fisher did not use an artificial intelligence tool in preparing his report, Plaintiff may answer by saying so. <em>Plaintiff need not disclose draft reports or communications between counsel</em> and Mr. Fisher, except as described in Section II.F.4.</p>
<p>Both sides request their expenses…. Because most of Defendants’ motion became moot after Plaintiff withdrew Dr. Jonyer, and the remaining request is granted only as narrowed, this Court declines to award expenses to either side.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *13 (cleaned up).</p>
<p>Another court recently took a more nuanced approach.  <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/experts-use-of-genai-was-proper-on-facts-presented/">Expert’s Use of GenAI Was Proper on Facts Presented</a> (Oct. 8, 2026).</p>
<p>For more information, please visit:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/even-with-an-error-experts-troubling-use-of-ai-as-a-thought-partner-did-not-undermine-expert-opinion/">Even With an Error, Expert’s “Troubling” Use of AI as a “Thought Partner” Did Not Undermine Expert Opinion</a> (Nov. 11, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/experts-use-of-genai-was-proper-on-facts-presented/">Expert’s Use of GenAI Was Proper on Facts Presented – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Oct. 8, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/opposing-experts-allegedly-inaccurate-description-of-use-of-a-i-did-not-justify-modification-of-scheduling-order-on-facts-presented/">Opposing Expert’s Allegedly Inaccurate Description of Use of A.I. Did Not Justify Modification of Scheduling Order on Facts Presented – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Sep. 15, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/show-how-3m-is-0-at-fault-expert-witness-used-chatgpt-to-write-report-defending-company-in-deadly-explosion-lawsuit/">“‘Show How 3M Is 0% at Fault:’ Expert Witness Used ChatGPT to Write Report Defending Company in Deadly Explosion Lawsuit” – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Aug. 26, 2026).</li>
</ul>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“Bar counsel goes to court over AI hallucinations in a first for MD &#8211; Maryland Daily Record”</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/bar-counsel-goes-to-court-over-ai-hallucinations-in-a-first-for-md-maryland-daily-record/</link>
		<pubDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 22:36:33 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[News Stories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Software]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sanctions]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5787</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Dan Belson, reports that Bar counsel goes to court over AI hallucinations in a first for MD &#8211; Maryland Daily Record (Nov. 17, 2026). Maryland’s Attorney Grievance Commission filed its first major court petition surrounding a lawyer’s use of artificial intelligence, seeking disciplinary action against a Prince George’s County attorney accused of<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dan Belson, reports that <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/2026/11/17/ai-hallucinations-bar-counsel-maryland/?utm_medium=email&amp;utm_source=Act-On+Software&amp;utm_content=Editorial&amp;utm_term=Read%20more&amp;utm_campaign=Breaking%3A%20Bar%20counsel%20goes%20to%20court%20over%20AI%20hallucinations%20in%20a%20first%20for%20MD&amp;ActOnUniqueID=MDDR151319">Bar counsel goes to court over AI hallucinations in a first for MD &#8211; Maryland Daily Record</a> (Nov. 17, 2026).</p>
<blockquote><p>Maryland’s <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/tag/attorney-grievance-commission/">Attorney Grievance Commission</a> filed its first major court petition surrounding a lawyer’s use of artificial intelligence, seeking disciplinary action against a Prince George’s County attorney accused of incorporating nonexistent cases and other legal inaccuracies <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/2026/05/19/ai-hallucinations-lawyers-maryland/">“hallucinated”</a> by <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/tag/chatgpt/">ChatGPT</a> into legal documents.</p>
<p>Investigators reviewed dozens of ChatGPT logs from <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/tag/upper-marlboro/">Upper Marlboro</a> attorney Samuel Q. Elira Sr. after a <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/tag/howard-county-circuit-court/">Howard County Circuit Court</a> judge scorned him last year for citing nonexistent cases <a href="https://thedailyrecord.com/2026/08/28/ai-hallucination-tech-tools/">hallucinated</a> by the chatbot in a motion he filed on behalf of a client. They also accused Elira of using the AI platform to draft responses to bar counsel inquiries concerning those fake citations.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>.  “Bar counsel investigators requested hundreds of pages-worth of Elira’s ChatGPT records, which confirmed that both of those statements had been written with the chatbot’s assistance, the filing says.”  <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p>“The Supreme Court of Maryland ordered Monday for an evidentiary hearing to be held before Prince George’s County Circuit Judge Althea R. Stewart Jones.”  <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p>For more information on AI issues in Maryland courts, please visit:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/maryland-has-developed-a-body-of-state-law-regarding-hallucinated-citations/">Maryland Has Developed a Body of State Law Regarding Hallucinated Citations – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/maryland-fake-citation-case-court-issues-a-warning-referral-to-atty-grievance-commn/">Maryland Fake Citation Case – Court Issues a Warning – Referral to Atty. Grievance Comm’n. – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/hallucinations-are-old-news-but-a-recent-maryland-decision-addresses-ethical-contours/">Hallucinations Are “Old News,” But a Recent Maryland Decision Addresses Ethical Contours  – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/maryland-copy-and-paste-hallucinations-case/">Maryland Copy and Paste “Hallucinations” Case – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/another-maryland-appellate-hallucinations-decision/">Another Maryland Appellate “Hallucinations” Decision – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/maryland-no-sanctions-for-apparent-hallucinations/">Maryland: No Sanctions for Apparent Hallucinations – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/md-lawyer-scolded-for-fake-citations-after-past-ai-issues/">“MD lawyer scolded for fake citations after past AI issues” – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/a-deep-dive-into-the-pikesville-md-racistantisemitic-deepfake-audio/">A Deep Dive Into the Pikesville, MD, Racist/Antisemitic Deepfake Audio – E-Discovery LLC</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/artificial-intelligence-in-maryland-courts/">Artificial Intelligence in Maryland Courts</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/marylands-facial-recognition-technology-statute/">Maryland’s Facial Recognition Technology Statute</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/criminal-conviction-reversed-after-state-failed-to-timely-fully-disclose-its-use-of-a-type-of-artificial-intelligence/">Criminal Conviction Reversed After State Failed to Timely &amp; Fully Disclose its Use of a Type of Artificial Intelligence</a>.</li>
</ul>
<p>Among other things, it is important for Maryland attorneys to be aware of:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/proposed-changes-to-the-md-attorneys-rules-of-professional-conduct-re-ai/">Proposed Changes to the MD Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct Re: AI</a> (Jul. 21, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/marylands-proposed-anti-hallucination-rule/">Maryland’s Proposed Anti-Hallucination Rule</a> (Mar. 16, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/childs-best-interest-trumps-sanction-for-possibly-hallucinated-case-citation/">Child’s Best Interest Trumps Sanction for Possibly Hallucinated Case Citation</a> (Mar. 15, 2026);</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/district-of-md-standing-order-re-genai-in-court-filings/">District of MD Standing Order re GenAI in Court Filings</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/district-of-maryland-hallucination-decision-2/">District of Maryland Hallucination Decision</a>;</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/a-i-policies-in-maryland-universities/">I. Policies in Maryland Universities</a>;</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/hallucinations-by-wests-cocounsel/">“Hallucinations” by West’s CoCounsel?</a> (Apr. 7, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/md-school-districts-face-fall-deadline-to-set-ai-policies/">“MD school districts face fall deadline to set AI policies”</a> (Jul. 7, 2026);</li>
<li>Sanctions and Remedies Where Parties Submit Citations Hallucinated by Artificial Intelligence Programs—State Cases, 110 A.L.R.7th Art. 3 (2026).</li>
</ul>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Allegation: “Meta&#8217;s &#8216;Privilege Abuse&#8217; Warrants Sanctions, MDL Judge Told &#8211; Law360”</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/metas-privilege-abuse-warrants-sanctions-mdl-judge-told-law360/</link>
		<pubDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 22:08:23 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[News Stories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Artificial Intelligence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Privilege]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5784</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[After apparently using GenAI for privilege review, “Meta downgraded its privilege designations on 56,747 of the 60,462 documents it had reviewed, or about 94%, according to the plaintiffs&#8217; motion on Friday. The plaintiffs say the results show Meta deliberately used attorney-client privilege to keep highly relevant evidence out of discovery.”  C.  Clouogh,<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>After apparently using GenAI for privilege review, “Meta downgraded its privilege designations on 56,747 of the 60,462 documents it had reviewed, or about 94%, according to the plaintiffs&#8217; motion on Friday. The plaintiffs say the results show Meta deliberately used attorney-client privilege to keep highly relevant evidence out of discovery.”  C.  Clouogh, <a href="https://www.law360.com/articles/2550267?e_id=7fe7d907-4062-41c6-ac59-7b72203db23a&amp;utm_source=engagement-alerts&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_campaign=recommended_articles&amp;utm_content=2026-11-17&amp;utm_marketing_tactic=1&amp;utm_creative_format=1&amp;read_main=1&amp;nlsidx=0&amp;nlaidx=0">Meta&#8217;s &#8216;Privilege Abuse&#8217; Warrants Sanctions, MDL Judge Told &#8211; Law360</a> (Nov. 16, 2026).</p>
<blockquote><p>&#8220;The scale, persistence, and direction of these reversals support the conclusion that Meta applied the privilege far too broadly and did so deliberately, rather than making isolated good-faith mistakes,&#8221; the plaintiffs say.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>.  The article reports that Meta has reserved a clawback right.  It adds that plaintiffs “ ask the court to let them use the downgraded documents with any witness or expert and to bar Meta from raising objections based on authenticity, foundation, personal knowledge or hearsay, while preserving objections under Federal Rule of Evidence 403. They also ask for a jury instruction allowing jurors to infer that Meta withheld the documents because it believed they were unfavorable to the company.”</p>
<p>According to Plaintiffs, “Meta cites its use of generative artificial intelligence in arguing it should retain the right to claw back documents. The plaintiffs ask the judge to require Meta to seek court permission and show good cause before clawing back any document produced through the review.”</p>
<p>Plaintiffs allege that Meta hid the risks of teen social media use. The MDL is In re: Social Media Adolescent Addiction/Personal Injury Products Liability Litigation, case number <a href="https://www.law360.com/cases/633f649f704893022631447d">4:22-md-03047</a>, in the <a href="https://www.law360.com/agencies/u-s-district-court-for-the-northern-district-of-california">U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California</a>.</p>
<p>This post is based on the Law360 article.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>An ESI Protocol is Not Rule-Mandated – A “Discovery Plan” Is Mandated</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/an-esi-protocol-is-not-rule-mandated-a-discovery-plan-is-mandated/</link>
		<pubDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:06:56 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[ESI Protocol a/k/a Discovery Plans]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Conference of Parties]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5781</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Plaintiff’s civil rights suit against several police officers arose out of his arrest after a traffic stop.  Parts of the occurrence were recorded by police cameras.  Plaintiff alleged “unlawful prolongation of the stop, unlawful search of the vehicle, false arrest, unlawful seizure of currency, and malicious prosecution.” Plaintiff filed a “Motion for<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Plaintiff’s civil rights suit against several police officers arose out of his arrest after a traffic stop.  Parts of the occurrence were recorded by police cameras.  Plaintiff alleged “unlawful prolongation of the stop, unlawful search of the vehicle, false arrest, unlawful seizure of currency, and malicious prosecution.”</p>
<p>Plaintiff filed a “Motion for Entry of a Proposed Order Governing Discovery of Electronically Stored Information.” It was described as a motion to enter an ESI Protocol.  Defendants filed an opposition and the motion was denied without prejudice.  <em>Halle v. Jansen</em>, 2026 WL 3458066 (S.D. Ill. Nov. 13, 2026). The court wrote:</p>
<blockquote><p>“<em>Entry of an ESI protocol is not rule-mandated. Absent a stipulation by the parties, the party seeking the entry of an ESI protocol has the burden of showing that there is good cause for its adoption</em>.”</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *1 (emphasis added).</p>
<p>Plaintiff failed, in my opinion, by seeking an ESI Protocol, instead of a “discovery plan,” and because of lack of an adequate factual foundation for a preservation order.</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/esi-protocol-v-discovery-plan/">“ESI Protocol” v. “Discovery Plan” – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Jan. 2, 2024);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/request-for-preservation-order-denied-under-the-cry-wolf-doctrine/">Request for Preservation Order Denied Under the “Cry Wolf” Doctrine – E-Discovery LLC</a> (May 31, 2026).</li>
</ul>
<p>As to the failure to provide a foundation, the court wrote that “the motion does not address why an ESI protocol is necessary in this case….”  <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p>However, the request was in significant part for a preservation order: “The proposed ESI protocol governs the preservation and identification of relevant ESI and provides for its production in a native format with metadata maintained.”  <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p>The court gave two reasons why an ESI Protocol was not needed to achieve these goals. <em>Id</em>.</p>
<p><em>First</em>, Fed.R.Civ.P. 34 allows Plaintiff to file a request for production of ESI and specify the form or forms of production.</p>
<p><em>Second</em>, as to preservation: “Defendants explain that CPD uses Axon for its camera services. Axon’s system collects data directly from CPD’s cameras and stores it on a cloud-based system. That system ‘generates permanent, tamper-proof audit trails that automatically log every action, such as viewing, editing, or sharing a file.’ … Defendants represent that while CPD can redact videos stored on Axon’s servers and create new videos as needed, all revisions are noted in Axon’s audit trails. As such, Plaintiff will have the ability to determine whether any produced videos have been edited. Defendants further state that they do not object to the production of original copies of relevant videos in their possession along with the corresponding audit trail for each video. Plaintiff will also be able to subpoena Axon if deemed necessary.”</p>
<p>On those facts, the court wrote: “Plaintiff has not filed a reply addressing Defendants’ objections or otherwise demonstrating the necessity for the entry of the proposed ESI protocol. Based on the record before it, the Court finds that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure in place adequately address any needs for ESI discovery in this case. Accordingly, the Motion for Entry of a Proposed Order Governing Discovery of Electronically Stored Information… is DENIED without prejudice.”  <em>Id</em>. at *2.</p>
<p>I suggest that Plaintiff misfired in two ways.  It is often important to use the correct words.  In “Through the Looking Glass,” Lewis Carroll wrote: “When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’”</p>
<p><em>First</em>, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure do not mention an “ESI Protocol.”  However, they do require a “discovery plan.”  <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/esi-protocol-v-discovery-plan/">“ESI Protocol” v. “Discovery Plan” – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Jan. 2, 2024); <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/an-esi-protocol-is-not-a-rule-26f-discovery-plan/">An “ESI Protocol” is Not a Rule 26(f) “Discovery Plan” – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Nov. 24, 2025).  A “discovery plan” includes all aspects of an ESI Protocol; however, an ESI Protocol may not suffice as a “discovery plan.”  Rule 26(f)(1) requires a conference of the parties “as soon as practicable….”  Under Rule 26(f)(2), the parties <em>must submit</em> “to the court within 14 days after the conference a written report outlining the [discovery] plan.”   A discovery plan is robust and defined in Rule 26(f)(3). Under Fed.R.Civ.P. 37(f): “If a party or its attorney fails to participate in good faith in developing and submitting a proposed discovery plan as required by Rule 26(f), the court may, after giving an opportunity to be heard, require that party or attorney to pay to any other party the reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, caused by the failure.”  <em>See also</em> <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/failure-to-cooperate-leads-to-judicially-imposed-esi-protocol/">Failure to Cooperate Leads to Judicially-Imposed ESI Protocol – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Jan. 15, 2025).</p>
<p><em>Second</em>, there is a well-developed body of case law governing preservation orders. <a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/the-standard-for-a-preservation-order/">The Standard for a Preservation Order – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Oct. 21, 2026).   A movant must provide the factual predicate:  “The parties generally agree that courts considering a preservation order should assess (i) the degree of concern that evidence will be destroyed, (ii) the risk of irreparable harm to the requesting party, and (iii) the preserving party’s capability to maintain the evidence in question.”  <em>Id</em>. (citation omitted).  Another test is whether the party seeking preservation can demonstrate both that an order is necessary and not unduly burdensome. <em>Id</em>. (citation omitted).  While the Plaintiff in <em>Halle</em> appears to have failed to make such a demonstration, Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(f) states topics that “the parties must consider” in a conference of the parties a/k/a a “meet and confer.”  One of them is to “discuss any issues about preserving discoverable information….” Further, the “discovery plan” developed by the parties should address “any issues about… preservation of electronically stored information….”  Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(f)(3)(C).  That rules-based discussion is not predicated on a showing of necessity.</p>
<p>In “Alice in Wonderland,” Lewis Carroll wrote “Begin at the beginning and go on till you come to the end: then stop.”  The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are a good starting point.</p>
<p>This blog was initially posted on  <a href="https://edrm.net/author/michaeldberman/">Electronic Discovery Reference Model</a>.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Request for Forensic Examination of Laptop Was Denied</title>
		<link>https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/request-for-forensic-examination-of-laptop-was-denied/</link>
		<pubDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 16:50:43 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Berman]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[District of MD]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ESI]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Experts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Software]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Forensics]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/?p=5779</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[In this breach of contract case arising out of an employment agreement, Defendant asked “that the Court compel Plaintiff to produce his personal laptop for a forensic examination….”  Evans v. Fortiline, Inc., 2026 WL 3216193 (D. Md. Oct. 27, 2026)(Coulson, J).  The former employer, Fortiline, asserted that the former employee, Mr. Evans,<span class="excerpt-hellip"> […]</span>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In this breach of contract case arising out of an employment agreement, Defendant asked “that the Court compel Plaintiff to produce his personal laptop for a forensic examination….”  <em>Evans v. Fortiline, Inc.</em>, 2026 WL 3216193 (D. Md. Oct. 27, 2026)(Coulson, J).  The former employer, Fortiline, asserted that the former employee, Mr. Evans, was “soliciting a current Fortiline employee to start a competing business in violation of his Employment Agreement.” Plaintiff disputed the allegation.  The request for a forensic examination was denied.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>THE FACTUAL PREDICATE</u></strong></p>
<p>Mr. Evans’ use of his personal laptop for Fortiline business was not in dispute:</p>
<blockquote><p>Defendant asserts that when it first employed Plaintiff, he “performed Fortiline work using his personal Apple laptop computer” after syncing “his Fortiline email account with his Apple email account, which allowed him to access his Fortiline email on his personal laptop.” &#8230; Plaintiff does not dispute that he used his personal laptop for Fortiline business for several months, with which he claims Defendant took no issue.</p></blockquote>
<p>It was undisputed that he had once sent company information to his Gmail account.</p>
<p>In its Request for Production of Documents, however, Defendant “included a request for forensic imaging of all electronic devices used by Plaintiff from March 1, 2025 to present in relation to his employment with Defendant.” In my view, that was a risky request:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/standard-for-court-ordered-forensic-examinations-when-does-misconduct-cross-the-rubicon/">Standard for Court-Ordered Forensic Examinations – When Does Misconduct “Cross the Rubicon”? – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Jul. 24, 2025)(“Courts have also looked to the existence of evasive behavior and purposeful delay…. Although cases describe various approaches and considerations pertinent to this issue, there is no precise formulation describing exactly when discovery misconduct crosses the Rubicon into territory warranting a forensic examination.” (citation omitted));</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/another-decision-on-forensic-imaging-of-an-opponents-cell-phone/">Another Decision on Forensic Imaging of an Opponent’s Cell Phone – E-Discovery LLC</a> (May 10, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/request-to-appoint-neutral-forensic-expert-denied-as-speculative-and-unsupported/">Request to Appoint Neutral Forensic Expert Denied as Speculative and Unsupported – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Jan. 28, 2025).</li>
</ul>
<p>Unsurprisingly, Plaintiff refused.  However, “Defendant states that Plaintiff also did not produce any emails or other Electronically Stored Information (‘ESI’), but upon review of materials in its possession, Defendant discovered that Plaintiff previously emailed Fortiline information to his personal Gmail containing “confidential/trade secret pricing information&#8230;.”  Plaintiff responded that the email was sent to that account by mistake.</p>
<p>However, “[i]n light of Defendant’s discovery, the parties met and conferred, during which Defendant claims that it learned <em>Plaintiff himself conducted a search of responsive documents, which did not include his personal email or laptop</em>.”  To say that was a risky practice is an understatement, especially where the searcher is directly involved in the merits. <em>See</em>:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/unsupervised-self-collection-the-fox-guarding-the-chicken-coop-leads-to-discovery-on-discovery/">Unsupervised Self Collection—The Fox Guarding the Chicken Coop—Leads to Discovery on Discovery – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Sep. 19, 2026);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/self-collection-discovery-about-discovery-and-curative-sanctions/">Self-Collection, Discovery About Discovery, and Curative Sanctions – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Sep. 22, 2024);</li>
<li><a href="https://www.ediscoveryllc.com/self-collection-may-be-reasonable-using-ralph-loseys-dual-protection-system/">“Self-Collection” May Be Reasonable Using Ralph Losey’s Dual-Protection System – E-Discovery LLC</a> (Jan. 19, 2024).</li>
</ul>
<p>Plaintiff ran two separate searches for “@fortiline.com” and (2) andrew.evans@fortiline.com&#8230;. Additionally, he ran searches for each of the following terms individually: “recruiter,” “headhunter,” “private equity,” “termination,” “fired,” “contract,” “Mark Boring,” “startup,” and “new business.”</p>
<p>Next, Mr. Evans made a supplemental production. Defendant asserted that this supplement “raised additional questions about what happened to the Fortiline information [Plaintiff] emailed to himself during his employment, and whether the searches done to date are adequate to find all responsive ESI.”</p>
<p>And, there was more: “Additionally, Defendant states that on October 12, 2026, it learned that Plaintiff had Fortiline documents on his personal laptop.”  Mr. Evans did not deny that but claimed that those documents were “’run of the mill’ and without relevance to any claims or defenses in the current litigation, but such documents will nevertheless be produced.”</p>
<p>To recap, at this juncture, Defendant had made an early request for a forensic examination, it was undisputed that Mr. Evans had used his personal laptop for company business for several months, after a search by Plaintiff apparently without attorney supervision, Mr. Evans initially failed to produce certain responsive materials and did so only after defense inquiry,  and even after a supplemental production, Mr. Evans’ production appeared incomplete.</p>
<p>In the Defendant’s words a forensic examination was justified because, “Defendant claims that Plaintiff’s prior ‘piecemeal and lackadaisical approach to searching for responsive documents raises questions about the sufficiency of his search efforts to date.’”  In response, “Plaintiff argues that Defendant’s request is not proportional given that he will provide Defendant with relevant non-privileged emails and documents.”</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong><u>DEFENDANT FAILED TO CARRY ITS BURDEN OF PROOF</u></strong></p>
<p>The <em>Evans</em> Court first explained that forensic examinations are not lightly ordered:</p>
<blockquote><p>Courts have been cautious in requiring the mirror imaging of computers where the request is extremely broad in nature and the connection between the computers and the claims in the lawsuit are unduly vague or unsubstantiated in nature….  As this Court has observed, a forensic examination imposes ‘intrusions, costs, and delays making it a “drastic discovery measure&#8230;that must be proportional to the needs of the case…. Mere skepticism that an opposing party has not produced all relevant information is not sufficient to warrant drastic electronic discovery measures.”</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. at *3 (cleaned up).</p>
<p>The <em>Evans</em> Court then set out when a forensic examination may be ordered:</p>
<blockquote><p>However, restrained and orderly computer forensic examinations have been permitted, where the moving party has demonstrated that the opposing party has defaulted in its discovery obligations by unwillingness or failure to produce relevant information by more conventional means…. In cases where the existence of a document on an electronic device would itself be probative of an issue in dispute, courts are more likely to find that the intrusions, costs, and delays attendant to a forensic examination are proportional to the needs of the case.</p></blockquote>
<p><em>Id</em>. (cleaned up).</p>
<p>Next, the Court explained where Fortiline fell short.  First, “it fails to suggest that Plaintiff deleted or otherwise destroyed responsive information that could only be obtained through forensic imaging….  Rather, Defendant relies on Plaintiff’s email to his personal Gmail to argue that responsive information is being withheld on the personal laptop. However, Defendants generalized allegations fail to make a showing sufficient to warrant an order allowing for the forensic imaging and examination of Plaintiff’s personal laptop.”  <em>Id</em>. at *3.</p>
<p>The <em>Evans</em> Court then looked at Plaintiff’s delay: “Also, while the Court is certainly mindful of Plaintiff’s delays in producing all relevant information to Defendant, both in producing emails and documents on the laptop, it does not find that Plaintiff’s brief delay justifies such an intrusive remedy at this juncture.”  <em>Id</em>. at *4.</p>
<p>And, in response to Defendant’s argument that it “is not obligated to take [Plaintiff’s] word about what&#8230;information he does/does not still possess,” the Court wrote: “Yet, that is precisely how discovery operates.” <em>Id</em>. at *4 (citation omitted).</p>
<p>Even though Defendant offered to pay the cost of the forensic examination, “both the privacy concerns and concerns about the scope of discovery related to Rule 26 clearly weigh against a forensic examination. Defendant has not carried its burden beyond mere suspicion that forensic imaging Plaintiff’s personal laptop is necessary to uncover relevant evidence unavailable through less intrusive means considering Plaintiff’s representations that no documents have been deleted from his laptop and all responsive information has been or will ultimately be produced.”  <em>Id</em>. at *4.</p>
<p>The Court emphasized: “To be clear, Defendant will still receive discovery from Plaintiff’s personal laptop. Even when a forensic examination is not warranted, the Federal Rules require a party to conduct a reasonable search of its files to determine whether it has responsive documents in its possession, custody, or control.”  <em>Id</em>. at *4 (cleaned up). And, it left the door open for a future request for a forensic examination upon a factual predicate.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
